Buying guide

Mattress Buying Tips from Local Experts

How to balance comfort and support, compare mattress types and test a bed like a pro.

Family relaxing on a new mattress

Sleep Facts

Interesting Tips & Info

The two things that matter most when buying a mattress are support (keeping your spine aligned and resisting sagging) and comfort (how the surface feels). Choose a feel that suits your sleep position, compare memory foam, hybrid and innerspring constructions, and test your top choices for 10 to 15 minutes each in a showroom.

Last reviewed October 20, 2026 by The Sleep Center team.

With so many brands, support systems, comfort levels and styles, mattress shopping can be overwhelming. Brent Spaulding, owner of The Sleep Center in Gainesville, is a co-author of The Mattress Professor, a consumer education guide to buying mattresses. Here are the key tips we share every day.

It's all about comfort and support

The most important things to consider are comfort and support. You want the right balance of both for your body.

Support holds your body weight evenly over time and keeps your back aligned. A supportive mattress gives balanced resistance that holds you in place and resists sagging.

Comfort is the feel of the top layers: plush, medium or firm. Side sleepers usually need more cushioning; back and stomach sleepers usually need more firmness.

Know the main mattress types

  • TEMPUR® material: Tempur-Pedic's own dense, slow-responding material adapts to your weight and temperature for deep pressure relief and almost no motion transfer. It feels unlike any other foam, so try it in person.
  • Memory foam: Contours closely to your body and absorbs motion. Great for pressure relief and couples; some sleep warmer.
  • Hybrid: Foam comfort layers over individually wrapped coils. Contouring with bounce, airflow and stronger edges.
  • Innerspring: A coil support system with a tight top or pillow top. A traditional, buoyant feel that is easy to move on.

Take a test rest

Different mattresses suit different bodies and lifestyles. The only way to know for sure is to lie down on them.

  1. Wear comfortable clothes

    Dress so you can lie down and change positions easily.

  2. Lie in your real sleep position

    Spend most of your time on your side, back or stomach, however you actually sleep.

  3. Give each bed 10 to 15 minutes

    First impressions change. Let your body settle into the mattress.

  4. Check your alignment

    Ask an expert to look at your spine. It should stay level, without hips sagging or shoulders jammed.

  5. Test with your partner

    If you share a bed, test motion transfer and edge support together.

  6. Narrow it to two

    Go back and forth between your final two until one clearly wins.

Don't forget the foundation and pillow

A new mattress on an old, sagging base won't perform as designed, and the wrong pillow can undo great support. Ask about adjustable bases, bed frames and pillows.

Mattress sizes we carry

Most sizes are in stock for fast delivery.

  • Twin39" × 75"
  • Twin XL39" × 80"
  • Full / Double54" × 75"
  • Queen60" × 80"
  • King76" × 80"
  • California King72" × 84"
  • Split Kingtwo 38" × 80"
  • Split California Kingtwo 36" × 84"

Questions about buying a mattress?

Talk with a mattress expert. No pressure, just answers.

Questions

More mattress tips

Straight answers from our mattress experts. Don't see yours? Ask us; we love questions.

Still have a question?

Call a showroom and talk to a real mattress expert.

Send us a message
How do I know when to replace my mattress?

Common signs are waking up stiff or sore, visible sagging or lumps, noisy springs, and sleeping better on other beds. Many mattresses last around 7 to 10 years.

What's the difference between comfort and support?

Support is how well the mattress keeps your spine aligned and resists sagging. Comfort is how the surface feels: plush, medium or firm. The right bed balances both for your body.

How long should I lie on a mattress in the store?

About 10 to 15 minutes on each of your top choices, in the position you actually sleep in.

Is a firmer mattress better for back pain?

Not always. Many people with back pain do best on a medium to medium-firm bed that keeps the spine aligned while cushioning pressure points. Try a few feels in your usual sleep position.

Should I rotate my mattress?

Most of today's mattresses are one-sided and shouldn't be flipped, but rotating head to foot every few months can help them wear evenly. Follow the manufacturer's care guide.

What size mattress should I get?

Couples usually prefer a queen or king; a king gives each sleeper about the width of a twin. See the mattress sizes chart on this page, and measure your room and doorways first.

Two showrooms

Take a test rest in Gainesville

Both stores are open seven days a week. No appointment needed; walk in, lie down and take your time.

Come lie down. Take your time.

Two Gainesville showrooms, open seven days. No appointment needed, and never any pressure.